Saturday, December 15, 2018 06:44 PM

Convergence Of The Attributes And Traits Between Space X And ISRO: Modi Must Join Hands With Musk For A Shot At Mars

"A one-km auto rickshaw ride in Ahmedabad takes Rs 10 and India reached Mars at Rs 7 per km, which is really amazing," Prime Minister Narendra Modi emphasised the achievement in his speech in New York in September 2014.

He was speaking about the inter-planetary plan of the Indian Space Research Organisation (ISRO) that has disrupted space technologies.
Elon Musk, a dangerously daring dreamer, at that time had a blueprint of a Martian journey on the drawing board of his SpaceX office in California. He not only wants to just send man to Mars, he wants to colonise it. He has planned on taking one million willing people from our blue planet Earth to the red planet by 2022, a journey of 650 million kilometres. To achieve this objective, he has to make the journey affordable and safe.
"Everything about Mangalyaan (ISRO's space craft to Mars) is indigenous. We reached Mars at a smaller budget than a Hollywood movie ("Gravity")," Modi stated smugly, adding that "India is the only country to reach Mars on its first attempt. If this is not talent, then what is?"
Indeed, India's Mars spacecraft catapulted the country into an elite club of three nations, that too at just $74 million. That was a tenth (about $670 million) of NASA's Mars mission "Maven" that entered the Martian orbit just two days before Modi's statement.
Surely, Elon Musk was listening to Modi. It must have been a shocker for him because his project to colonise Mars had, and still has, the same objectives as ISRO's -- to reduce space transportation and pay-load carrying costs.
Within the next three years SpaceX developed a family of Falcon-series launch vehicles and the Dragon spacecraft, both of which deliver payloads into the Earth's orbit at low cost mainly because Musk is able to bring back the launch vehicle for reuse.
During the same three years, ISRO became one of the world's top space-runners. It is now a technology giant that is championing and taming space launches. It is no longer just a government-funded agency but a commercial venture that can launch other countries' satellites through its massive launch vehicles -- the GSLVs and the PSLVs. These are capable of carrying heavy payloads of satellites into space.
The ambitions, aspirations and potential of ISRO and Space X have started to demonstrate amazingly clear similarity.
When Space X was busy announcing the contract with two private individuals to send them in a Dragon spacecraft around the Moon, ISRO had already fired its PSLV and launched 104 satellites into space from a single vehicle. While Moon tourism is Space X's business proposition, taking other countries' satellites into space is ISRO's.
Of the 104 satellites launched at one go, a whopping 96 belonged to the US, which paid India for the launch. The satellites, released in rapid-fire fashion every few seconds from a single rocket as it travelled at 30,000 kms an hour is like testing the limits of technology.
On January 12, 2018, ISRO soared again. This time it launched 31 satellites during a single mission that included three of India's and 28 of other countries. When the last of the satellite was ejected, it was the 100th satellite of ISRO.
A month later, on February 6, 2018, Elon Musk recaptured the headlines as the Falcon Heavy 9 vehicle, the most powerful ever developed after the one that took man to moon, had carried a payload of his Tesla Roadster with dummy driver into space and toward the Asteroid belt.
It was sort of a gimmick and fun, as per Musk. However, more importantly, the mission was able to bring back to the earth two of the three launch vehicles and they were recovered. The same did not happen with the third vehicle.
ISRO has also announced that it is planning a flight with a "dummy crew module", which is part of a programme for the development of critical technologies that it seeks to develop as part of its "human space-flight programme".
Now is the time for Modi and Musk to collaborate as equal partners, particularly under Modi's pet project of "Make in India". Both of them need to recognise this as there are not only excellent convergence of the attributes and traits between Space X and ISRO, but also between Musk and Modi.
All of Elon Musk's projects -- electric cars that have captured the imagination of almost all governments, lithium batteries that can break long-standing barriers for solar energy, Tesla Solar Roof Tiles that can turn every home into a power plant, car elevators and Underground Tunnels that will drastically reduce use of fossil fuels, Hyperloop for sustainable transport -- are all path-breaking innovations that can make dependence on fossil fuels history.
Modi has a unique opportunity for de-politicising climate change and space exploration, and take global leadership by partnering with Musk. It would in turn help Indian aspirations of eradicating poverty and making gainful employment.
(Rajendra Shende is Chairman, TERRE Policy Centre, and Director, UNEP. The views expressed are personal. He can be contacted at


Why am I educated?

One of my uncles visited my house on a Sunday and hoped to find us in a weekend holiday mood. To his great surprise, I was not available at home. ..


Impeachment, My Lord!

The impeachment motion moved by opposition parties is an inevitable attempt to resolve the serious issues raised by four senior most judges. The Constitution allows for such a parliamentary scrutiny when things in judiciary go wrong. The..


Challenges before Kodandaram’s TJS

Yet another political party descended on the Telangana political horizon with Prof. Kodandaram transforming the Telangana Joint Action Committee (TJAC) into Telangana Jana Samithi (TJS). But, challenges galore for the professor turned..


Be humble, it costs nothing

Amitabh Bachchan once narrated an anecdote that he was part of, which when read in all its richness brings the virtues of a down-to-earth extraordinary individual. ..


Hacking Democracy with Big Data, Fake News and Big Money

STARTING with the Channel 4 exposé of Cambridge Analytica, and now the NaMo app that sends data to, we are beginning to realise the impact of big data on elections. If we combine this with fake news – the recent MIT report that..


Interference of the Government in the Judicial appointments

The nation is concerned with the latest developments arising from the letter written by the Senior most  Judge of the Supreme Court and Second ranking Judge of the Supreme Court's Collegium about interference of the Government in the Judicial..


Jagan’s Resignations Salvo to irk Chandrababu

YSR Congress announced that its MPs would resign on the last day of parliament session if the no-confidence motion is not taken up and special status is thus denied again. The party is exerting pressure on TDP to also seek the resignation of..


Whither fighting BJP in its idiom

Mamata Banerjee's new-found interest in Rama Navami celebrations, and Congress president's unending visits to temples indicate opposition’s desperation to take on Narendra Modi in 2019 by countering BJP's politics of Hindutva, with either..


Jittery BJP makes 3 Goof Ups

The Congress poked fun at Amit Shah saying it agreed with his description of Karnataka's Yeddyurappa government as "number one" in corruption in a gleeful reference to a gaffe made by the BJP president when he sought to mention Siddaramaiah but..