Thursday, May 23, 2019 11:02 AM

UP Formula  of vote pooling to defeat BJP

THE BJP has suffered a shock defeat in the two by-elections to the Lok Sabha seats of Gorakhpur and Phulpur. In the 2014 Lok Sabha election, these two seats were won by Yogi Adityanath, now chief minister and Keshav Prasad Maurya, now deputy chief minister with a margin of over 3 lakh votes each. This time around the seats were won by Samajwadi Party candidates who were supported by its arch rival, the BSP.

 There is no doubt that these results will have significant implications for the future. The BJP had won 71 out of the 80 seats in UP in the 2014 Lok Sabha elections decimating its rivals SP and BSP who got a tally of 5 and 0 seats respectively.

 How did this stunning result come about? The SP and the Congress had fielded candidates in both seats. The BSP in keeping with its long held policy of not contesting by-elections had not done so. But just a week before polling, the BSP announced its support for the SP in both seats. In an impressive ground level campaign, BSP workers were able to convey the message to BSP supporters to vote for the “cycle”. The results show that this unity led to a consolidation of votes of the OBCs, dalits and minorities. Apart from that, there was a swing away from the BJP, one of the factors being, the record of one year of the Yogi government.

 In UP this was the first time SP and BSP worked together in an election. Many people have talked about the 1993 assembly election as the first time they cooperated. But actually, there was no pre-poll alliance at that time. It was only after the election that the two parties came together to form a government with Mulayam Singh as the chief minister. The alliance fell apart in two years time, never to have any cooperation till now.

 The UP by-election provides important lessons for the future in terms of election tactics to defeat the BJP. If the BJP loses the bulk of the seats in UP, it cannot come anywhere near a majority in the Lok Sabha. If the major non-BJP parties unite, then the smaller parties and forces can extend support to them. In this instance, the Left parties, following BSP’s announcement, declared support for the SP candidates; so did other smaller parties. The Congress which did not withdraw from the elections got a poor vote and lost its deposits. However, it remains to be seen if the two parties can sustain a longer term cooperation beyond the tentative step taken for these by-elections and the Rajya Sabha polls.

 The second lesson is that the effective way to take on the BJP in the Lok Sabha election is not by forging an all-India alliance or front of all opposition parties. The Congress hopes to build an extended UPA style alliance to counter the BJP. However, this will not succeed.  The Congress has no credibility to lead such an alliance in terms of an alternative programme.  There are many regional parties like the BJD in Odisha, the TRS in Telangana and the TDP in Andhra Pradesh who will not accept to be a partner in an alliance with the Congress. There are other parties who are chary of accepting the Congress as the leader of the alliance. The CPI (M) has already declared it will not be part of a national alliance with the Congress.

 Similarly, any effort to build a non-BJP, non-Congress “federal front” mooted by the Telangana chief minister KCR, is bound to fail. Some of the regional parties like DMK and RJD are with Congress in their respective states. Further, there are many contradictions amongst the regional parties in terms of policies and regional interests which will prevent all the regional parties coming together.

 So, the most effective electoral tactics to defeat the BJP in the Lok Sabha election will be to ensure pooling of anti-BJP votes state-wise. This is what happened in the UP by-elections.



Impeachment, My Lord!

The impeachment motion moved by opposition parties is an inevitable attempt to resolve the serious issues raised by four senior most judges. The Constitution allows for such a parliamentary scrutiny when things in judiciary go wrong. The..


Challenges before Kodandaram’s TJS

Yet another political party descended on the Telangana political horizon with Prof. Kodandaram transforming the Telangana Joint Action Committee (TJAC) into Telangana Jana Samithi (TJS). But, challenges galore for the professor turned..


Hacking Democracy with Big Data, Fake News and Big Money

STARTING with the Channel 4 exposé of Cambridge Analytica, and now the NaMo app that sends data to, we are beginning to realise the impact of big data on elections. If we combine this with fake news – the recent MIT report that..


Interference of the Government in the Judicial appointments

The nation is concerned with the latest developments arising from the letter written by the Senior most  Judge of the Supreme Court and Second ranking Judge of the Supreme Court's Collegium about interference of the Government in the Judicial..


Jagan’s Resignations Salvo to irk Chandrababu

YSR Congress announced that its MPs would resign on the last day of parliament session if the no-confidence motion is not taken up and special status is thus denied again. The party is exerting pressure on TDP to also seek the resignation of..


Whither fighting BJP in its idiom

Mamata Banerjee's new-found interest in Rama Navami celebrations, and Congress president's unending visits to temples indicate opposition’s desperation to take on Narendra Modi in 2019 by countering BJP's politics of Hindutva, with either..


Jittery BJP makes 3 Goof Ups

The Congress poked fun at Amit Shah saying it agreed with his description of Karnataka's Yeddyurappa government as "number one" in corruption in a gleeful reference to a gaffe made by the BJP president when he sought to mention Siddaramaiah but..